You tell us:

If you were forced to choose, which would you go without:?
Food 23.21 %
Wine 76.79 %
( 336 Votes)
For a two-course meal, would you prefer dessert or entree?
Dessert 44.94 %
Entree 55.06 %
( 316 Votes)

- Podcasts
- News

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner



25 Market Lane, Melbourne, VIC 3000
Ph: (03) 96500848
Prices: Degustation $100+
Style: Modern, original Japanese
26th Apr 2018

Our top 5's:

Dave and Alicia's Best :
  1 : Tetsuya's
  2 : Attica
  3 : Vue de Monde
  4 : Bistro Guillaume
  5 : Rockpool Bar and Grill
Lachie & Sarah's Picks :
  1 : Attica
  2 : Jacques Reymond
  3 : The Lake House
  4 : Pearl
  5 : Matteo's

Quick Links:

Featured Links:
  Enoteca Sileno

News Archives:
  Mar 2018
  Feb 2018
  Jan 2018
  Dec 2017
  Nov 2017
  Oct 2017
  Show all


Review by Dave
Melbourne's Own Iron Chef?

If you're a fan of food, chances are you're a fan of the TV show Iron Chef - a quirky, typically Japanese cooking show involving unusual ingredients and unusual results. I've been a fan of this show for years, and have often wondered what it would be like to try such European influenced Japanese flavours, like those presented by my idol, Hiroyuki Sakai. In Shoya, Melbourne may have found its very own Iron Chef in head Chef Shigeo Nonaka. Be warned: this is not Japanese like you've had before - it's far better!

Shoya actually comprises six levels, each providing a difference experience: from fine dining through to Karaoke (I'd skip the latter!). On the mid level dedicated to fine dining, we were greeted by simple, elegant decor and somewhat traditional Japanese feel, despite the lack of tatami matting. Compared with the surrounding elegance, the disposable wooden snap-type chopsticks were a jarring, out-of-place reminder of the corner noodle house, but were quickly forgotten when the food began to flow.

The menu is almost a small novel, and accordingly diners are encouraged to sample the full range of the chef's dishes from one of the several degustation menus on offer. Changes to the degustation menus are possible, but it's best to speak to the head waiter to request them. We changed only one dish from the menu we chose, replacing a poached salmon with a slow braised ox tongue, due to a recommendation from a friend.

Service for the most part was fairly good, although highly variable. While our head waiter was extremely knowledgeable and competent, some of the more junior wait staff could benefit from a few basic lessons. A few smiles and laughs later though the drinks were in the glass rather than the table - no harm no foul, and a minor hiccup in the grand scheme of things to come.

The winelist is extensive, particularly for an Asian restaurant: we ordered by the glass, but by the bottle offerings are quite good and varied, and while not cheap, the markup is typical for an establishment of this standard. Of particular note is the huge selection of quality Sakes on offer. Although I rarely partake of Sake, the selection would surely boggle the mind of any aficionado.

The food is where Shoya really excels. Each dish is meticulously crafted, from the Sashimi served in an ice bowl, to the 500-day grain fed grade 9 Wagyu beef, each dish is an amazing construction, demonstrating the finest Japanese traditions while constantly expanding the borders of Japanese cuisine. Of particular note were the Unitama (Sea urchin roe, Salmon roe, scrambled egg), Unagi canape (grilled eel, served with crab meat and shaved black truffle) and the dish we added to our menu: Gyu-Tan Koshu-Ni (ox tongue stewed for 2 days with red wine).

All in all, Shoya clearly deserves its chef's hat rating, for the outstanding food, if nothing else. We may never get to taste the food of the Iron Chefs, but perhaps Chef Shigeo can give them a run for their money, and become Melbourne's own Iron Chef?

We ate:
Shoya Degustation Menu, $150pp
Unagi Canape
Wagyu Tartar
Broiled Duck Shoya Style
Assortment of Sashimi
Crab & Hotate Fillo Age with Namashii Hotate
7 Lucky Godís Sachet
Gyu-Tan Koshu-Ni
Wagyu Steak
Mixed Rice & Miso Soup
Chefís Dessert

We drank:
Maude 2007 Sauvignon Blanc (New Zealand)
Yabby Lake 2005 Chardonnay (Mornington)


Your Comments...
  Posted by Disappointed , 02:46pm Mon, 9th May, 2011
    Was at Shoya Japanese Restaurant (near Flower Drum) last Saturday night 7th May 2011. Had heard about it and our party decided to check it out. The food was alright, modern Japanese, with some dishes extremely good. However, the great letdown was the atmosphere and service. We were seated in what we thought was the private rear areas where seating was the 'traditional' shoes off before steping up to the wooden podium kind. There was an out of control kid at one of the tables making noise all evening, pointing gunlike at those of us at other tables yelling 'bang! bang!' and dancing like he was on stage etc while his parents just indulged this obnoxious behaviour. While this is not the fault of the restaurant, the trouble was the head waitress, a large woman, not only made no effort to control this child, she was clearly a friend of the child's mother and indulged him further! This carried on all evening while the head waitress chatted happily with her friend and the rest of us struggled to get her attention to place orders for more drinks etc. Worse yet, the child routinely hovered, saliva flying, over the place where the food was staged before arriving at our tables, almost touching it and no attempt was made to prevent him! It was all we could do not to gag on what we were consuming. The other staff seemed pretty powerless and did their best but in the end, we just gave up trying to order more or anything. Totally ruined the ambience and experience. They definitely need to improve their management and clean up their act. What a waste.
Leave a comment:
(Will not be displayed)
Alert me to replies to my post (Email req'd)
Type the word in the image:

Reload Image





All content copyright © 2008 Gourmet Husbands. For privacy statement, please click here